Montaigne on Partisanship: A Lesson in Fraternal Connection
In 1580, Michel de Montaigne published a brief but piercing text on the dangers of blind partisanship. His observation that we tend to diminish our enemies and inflate our allies struck a nerve that resonates to this day. For Freemasons — who hold brotherhood and the pursuit of truth among their highest values — this sixteenth-century essay offers a surprisingly relevant mirror. The Historical Context of Montaigne’s Warning Michel de Montaigne wrote his essays during the bloody French Wars of Religion, a period in which Catholics and Huguenots fought one another with a fanaticism that laid entire cities to waste. The St. Bartholomew’s Day massacre of 1572, in which thousands of Protestants were slaughtered, was still fresh in collective memory when Montaigne took up his pen. Amid this climate of religious hatred and political division, he chose an unusual stance: the stance of nuance. In essay thirty of his first book, titled Of a Defect in Our Partisanship, Montaigne argued that we systematically fail to judge others fairly. We praise our allies beyond their merits and diminish our opponents below their actual qualities. This tendency, he maintained, undermines not only the truth but our own integrity as well. The Heart […]